
Money Bills for UPSC CSE Preparation
1. Introduction to
Money Bills
A Money Bill in India is a legislative proposal that deals
exclusively with fiscal matters such as taxation, government spending,
borrowing, and other financial obligations. Governed by Article 110 of the
Indian Constitution, Money Bills are distinct from other types of legislation
due to their specific content and the unique procedure prescribed for their
passage.
2. Definition and
Characteristics of a Money Bill
Key Characteristics:
- Scope: A Money Bill includes matters like
imposition, abolition, remission, alteration, or regulation of any tax;
borrowing by the government; expenditure from the Consolidated Fund of
India, and more.
- Exclusive Introduction in Lok
Sabha: Money Bills can only be
introduced in the Lok Sabha and require prior recommendation by the
President.
- Restricted Role of Rajya Sabha: The Rajya Sabha cannot amend Money Bills
but can recommend amendments, which the Lok Sabha may accept or reject.
The Rajya Sabha must return a Money Bill with recommendations within 14
days, failing which the bill is deemed passed
Procedural Aspects:
- Certification by Speaker: The Speaker of the Lok Sabha certifies a
bill as a Money Bill, and this decision is final and binding.
- Presidential Assent: After approval by both houses, a Money
Bill is sent to the President for assent. The President can either give
assent or withhold it but cannot return the bill for reconsideration.
3. Types of Money
Bills
Money Bills are typically classified into two categories based on
their function within the fiscal framework of the government:
Financial Bill
- Nature: These include legislative proposals that
involve amendments to tax laws or other financial laws, usually introduced
alongside the Union Budget.
- Procedure: Like other Money Bills, Financial Bills
must originate in the Lok Sabha and are subject to the same procedural
restrictions concerning Rajya Sabha's involvement.
Appropriation Bill
- Purpose: This type of Money Bill authorizes the
withdrawal of funds from the Consolidated Fund of India to meet
governmental expenditure for the fiscal year.
- Process: The Appropriation Bill is introduced
after the annual budget is passed and allows the government to allocate
funds to various heads of expenditure as approved by Parliament.
4. Legislative
Process for a Money Bill
The legislative journey of a Money Bill is streamlined to expedite
the passage of financial legislation critical for government functioning:
1.
Introduction: Only a Minister can introduce a Money Bill in the Lok Sabha.
2.
Rajya
Sabha Review: After passing in the Lok Sabha,
the bill is sent to the Rajya Sabha for recommendations, not amendments.
3.
Time
Constraint: The Rajya Sabha must return the bill within
14 days, after which it is considered passed in the form it was received from
the Lok Sabha.
4.
Presidential
Assent: The final step involves the President's
assent, after which the bill becomes law.
5. Distinction from
Financial Bills
While Money Bills deal exclusively with the core fiscal functions
of the government, Financial Bills might contain other non-financial elements
but still pertain to revenue or expenditure. The crucial difference lies in the
Rajya Sabha's powers—unlike Money Bills, Financial Bills can be amended or
rejected by the Rajya Sabha, and in some cases, may even lead to a joint
sitting of Parliament if there is a deadlock.
6. Importance in
UPSC Examination
Understanding the nature, types, and procedural nuances of Money
Bills is crucial for UPSC candidates, especially for General Studies Paper II
(Polity and Governance). Questions can range from direct identification and
characteristics of Money Bills to more analytical questions involving their
impact on governance and fiscal policy.
7. Conclusion
Money Bills play a pivotal role in ensuring the government has the
necessary funds to conduct its operations while maintaining parliamentary
oversight. For UPSC aspirants, a deep understanding of Money Bills not only
aids in exams but also provides insights into the broader mechanisms of fiscal
governance in India. This knowledge is essential for any aspiring civil
servant, reflecting the practical implications of fiscal policy and legislative
procedures in the governance of the country.
Practice MCQs on Money Bills for UPSC Preparation
Question 1
Which of the following statements is true regarding the
introduction of a Money Bill in the Parliament of India?
A) It can be introduced in either house of Parliament.
B) It must be introduced in the Rajya Sabha.
C) It can only be introduced in the Lok Sabha by a Minister with
the President's recommendation.
D) It can be introduced by any member of Parliament in the Lok
Sabha.
Answer: C
Explanation: A Money Bill can only be
introduced in the Lok Sabha by a Minister and requires prior recommendation
from the President, as per Article 110 of the Indian Constitution. This ensures
that fiscal measures are tightly controlled and originate from the executive
branch of the government.
Question 2
What happens if the Rajya Sabha does not return a Money Bill passed
by the Lok Sabha within 14 days?
A) The bill lapses and must be reintroduced.
B) It is considered passed in the form it was passed by the Lok
Sabha.
C) The President can call a joint session of Parliament to discuss
the bill.
D) The Supreme Court decides the next course of action.
Answer: B
Explanation: If the Rajya Sabha does not return
a Money Bill within 14 days, it is considered passed in the exact form it was
passed by the Lok Sabha. This provision ensures a swift legislative process for
financial legislation critical to the government's functioning.
Question 3
Which of the following is not a characteristic of a Money Bill?
A) It includes elements such as the imposition or abolition of
taxes.
B) It needs to be passed by a two-thirds majority in both houses.
C) The Speaker of the Lok Sabha certifies it as a Money Bill.
D) The Rajya Sabha can suggest amendments but cannot make changes
directly.
Answer: B
Explanation: A Money Bill does not require a
two-thirds majority to pass; it only requires a simple majority in the Lok
Sabha. The Rajya Sabha can suggest amendments, but these are not binding on the
Lok Sabha. The Speaker of the Lok Sabha's certification as a Money Bill is
final and cannot be challenged.
Question 4
What role does the President of India play in the enactment of a
Money Bill?
A) The President can suggest amendments to the Money Bill.
B) The President can veto a Money Bill and send it back for
reconsideration.
C) The President must give or withhold assent to a Money Bill; he
cannot return it.
D) The President plays no role in the process of a Money Bill.
Answer: C
Explanation: Once a Money Bill has been passed
by Parliament, the President can either assent to or withhold assent from the
bill. However, unlike with other types of bills, the President cannot return a
Money Bill for reconsideration by Parliament.
Question 5
Which of the following scenarios would qualify a bill as a Money
Bill?
A) A bill imposing fines for environmental violations.
B) A bill introducing new agricultural subsidies to be paid from
the Consolidated Fund of India.
C) A bill regulating the salaries of government employees without
any new imposition of taxes.
D) A bill establishing new guidelines for state governments to
impose property taxes.
Answer: B
Explanation: A bill qualifies as a Money Bill
if it deals with the imposition, abolition, remission, alteration, or
regulation of any tax or the appropriation of moneys out of the Consolidated
Fund of India. Subsidies paid from the Consolidated Fund directly relate to
government spending, a key characteristic of Money Bills. Other options do not
specifically deal with central government taxation or expenditure from national
funds, and hence would not qualify as Money Bills.
UPSC Mains Practice Question on Money Bills
Question:
"Money Bills play a crucial role in maintaining the financial
discipline of the government but also highlight the limitations in the powers
of the Rajya Sabha in financial governance." Critically analyze the
statement, as per Article 110 of the Indian Constitution.
Answer Framework:
Introduction:
- Define a Money Bill as outlined
in Article 110 of the Indian Constitution, emphasizing its exclusive
concern with financial matters such as taxation, borrowings, and
government spending.
Body:
1. Necessity of
Money Bills:
- Swift Legislative Action: Explain how the special procedure for
Money Bills ensures quick decision-making on critical financial matters,
vital for effective governance.
- Fiscal Responsibility: Discuss the role of Money Bills in
ensuring that decisions regarding the nation’s finances are taken with due
deliberateness, involving only those directly elected by the public (Lok
Sabha) and reviewed by the President.
- Budgetary Management: Illustrate how Money Bills facilitate
streamlined budgetary processes, allowing for orderly appropriation and
allocation of funds, crucial for running government schemes and services.
2. Constraints
Imposed by Money Bills:
- Limited Role of Rajya Sabha: Critique the reduced role of the Rajya
Sabha in the Money Bill process, where it can only make recommendations
that are not binding on the Lok Sabha, potentially undermining the
bicameral structure of Parliament.
- Democratic Deficit: Argue that the restricted participation
of the Rajya Sabha may lead to a lack of comprehensive scrutiny, which is
often required in financial governance.
- Potential for Misuse: Discuss instances or potential scenarios
where the classification of a bill as a Money Bill might be used to bypass
rigorous debate in both houses, leading to executive dominance over the
legislature.
Conclusion:
- Summarize the dual aspects of
Money Bills highlighting how they enable efficient fiscal management while
also potentially limiting broader legislative scrutiny and debate.
- Suggest measures to enhance the
role of the Rajya Sabha in the process without compromising the efficiency
of financial governance, such as clearer criteria for what constitutes a
Money Bill or a mechanism for a more collaborative review process between both
houses.
Other Important Links
|
Follow us on-
|
ADMISSIONS OPEN For Details, Contact
us- 9711394350 / 9717724350 |
Comments on “Money Bills for UPSC CSE Preparation”